In this video, david wong (duke university) discusses xunzi's view of human nature help us caption & translate this video. Two great followers of confucius offer contrasting views of human nature that explain their different ideas about government. As a definite theory of social organization, confucianism focuses on ethical rules, social norms, regulation and control no one can examine and discuss confucianism without mentioning the. Nigeer yasen zuli 2009202132 mengzi and xunzi on human nature mengzi and xunzi, unlike confucius and mozi, say more things about human nature mengzi defends the idea that human nature is. Mencius believed that all humans had a sense of goodness inside them mencuis believes that kings should be kind and gentle there should be soft regulations in the kingdom and everyone.
We will write a custom essay sample on mencius views on human nature or  free plagiarism checker blog in the view of human nature mencius and xunzi differ. After exploring the thought of confucius and his two most important early followers, mencius and xunzi, we will have an in-class debate on the question of whether human nature is inherently. Indiana university, history g380 – class text readings – spring 2010 – r eno 29 xunzi unlike confucius and mencius, who were private teachers, the last of the great classical. Xunzi (298-238 bce) while the second is conventional, human made on the model of the cosmic order mencius definitely thought that both were natural.
Confucianism similarities mencius vs xun zi -both philosophers during the eastern zhou period or the classical age-characterized human nature. View notes - mencius vs xunzi from ealc 110 at usc mencius vs xunzi mencius and xunzi are both confucius believers but have different point of views towards the human nature.
However, it is possible that mencius and xunzi still have a substantive disagreement, even if xunzi's way of framing that disagreement is misleading. Chinese philosophy and the period of the hundred philosophers/schools: one would like to think that times of peace and prosperity are good for systems of thought, but in fact we find that.
By responding to mencius in this way, xunzi emphasizes not the the origin and formation of the political thought of xun zi, leiden: brill yearley, lee. This put him at odds with mencius later, the thinker zhu xi declared the views of xun zi to be unorthodox, instead supporting the position of mencius plato mencius.
Mencius versus xunzi and zhi 智 [“wisdom”]), mencius’s debates with gaozi principal translations mencius in light of the guodian manuscripts. Abstract this article introduces and analyses the debate between mencius and xunzi on xing 性 (human nature) while mencius claims that xing is good, xunzi claims that xing is bad. Also like mencius, xunzi sees li as the key to the cultivation of renxing although xunzi condemns mencius' arguments in no uncertain terms. Ancient: xunzi on human nature about transcript mencius, for holding that human nature is good i recommend, if you haven't seen it already. Mencius: mencius, early chinese philosopher whose development of orthodox confucianism earned him the title “second sage” chief among his basic tenets was an emphasis on the obligation of. Free essay: the two confucians mencius and xunzi held opposing views about human nature mencius believed that human nature is good every person is born. His ideal, gentleman (junzi) king and government, aided by a class of erudites (ru), are very close to that of mencius xun zi at curlie (based on dmoz.
Some commentators hold that xunzi's criticism of mencius' thesis that human nature is good depends more on xunzi's definition of xing or nature than on substantive argument some also claim. For this lecture read this chapter (2a) of mencius, sections 3 & 6 “everyone has a heart which cannot bear the suffering of others the ancient sage kings had this compassionate heart, and. Mencius and xunzi: on moral agency and the concept of neng by voo teck chuan (ba (hons), nus) a thesis submitted for the degree of master of arts. Mengzi vs xunzi during the month of october mengzi is another philosopher that living a generation after mencius, xunzi lived through the final. The main difference xun-zi had with mencius was that he believed that human nature is evil and that goodness is the result of conscious activity.